November 19, 2026
In the mid-1930s, the Sisters, Servants of the Immaculate Heart of Mary bought 4½ acres at 111th Street and First Avenue for $2,000. In 1937 they built Villa Maria by the Sea there, a three-story retreat house for 250 sisters. The sisters used it as a summer retreat for more than 80 years. This past September, they sold a single lot from that land, 137 111th Street, for $4,050,000.
The jump from $2,000 to $4 million makes a good story, but buyers comparing shore towns should look at what happened after 2023. The sisters have been selling lots from the same few blocks for three years, so the county deed records give a steady reading of Stone Harbor land prices. Over that time, land prices have barely changed. Some of the same parcels have resold for far more than the land cost.
In 2019, NJ.com reported that the sisters planned to demolish the old building, sell part of the land and rebuild. They cited fewer and older sisters, trouble finding staff, and rising maintenance, utility and tax costs. Sister James Dolores, who managed the property, told the outlet the sale would give them "adequate funds to demolish, to rebuild" and help "sustain the operational costs." Seven Mile Times described a 13-lot residential subdivision next to a smaller new Villa by the ocean. Lot sales would pay for the demolition, the new building and its upkeep, and Sister James called the old building "too big" and "too costly."
Ground was broken for the new Villa on September 27, 2021, and it was dedicated on May 15, 2023. The Catholic Star Herald reported that spring that part of the old property had been sold to cover the cost of the new building. The lots the sisters have sold are on 111th Street, 112th Street and Second Avenue.
The Cape May County Herald's deed database shows the sisters selling these lots in three rounds:
| Year recorded | Lots sold by the sisters | Prices |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 7 | $3,595,000 to $5,250,000, plus $11,250,000 for 105 112th St. |
| 2025 | 2 | $4,150,000 and $4,350,000 |
| 2026 | 4 | $3,800,000 to $4,125,000 |
Two lots on 112th Street sold for the most, 105 112th Street for $11.25 million in December 2023 and 115 112th Street for $5.25 million that July. Every other lot sold between $3,595,000 and $4,350,000. Lot prices recorded in 2023, 2025 and 2026 fall in that same band. In January 2026, 11100 Second Avenue sold for $4,125,000 and 11116 Second Avenue sold for $4,100,000. In September, 11108 Second Avenue sold for $3,800,000. The 2026 lots sold for about the same as the 2023 lots.
Some of these lots have already sold a second time, and the difference between the two prices is where the value has grown.
On June 16, 2023, an LLC bought 155 112th Street from the sisters for $3,995,000. On June 27, 2025, that LLC sold the property for $7,500,000. On the same day in 2023, a different LLC bought 145 112th Street for $4,295,000. It sold that property on August 21, 2026, for $7,350,000. Each lot cost roughly $4 million and resold for about $3 million more, one just over two years later and the other three years and two months later.
11200 Second Avenue sold for $3,595,000 in June 2023 and again on April 29, 2026, for $4,087,500. That is a gain of $492,500 in nearly three years, and the 2026 price still falls inside the band of lot prices in the table above. Those three resales are the evidence for the pattern. The land price stayed near $4 million, and the price gap at resale ran from under $500,000 to about $3.5 million.
The old Villa grounds are just the easiest place in Stone Harbor to see this, because one seller sold many lots in a short span. Deed records from other blocks show the same thing.
In November 2024, an LLC called Charles Street Developers bought a property at 8331 First Avenue for $4,200,000. The same block and lot is now recorded as 8337 First Avenue. It sold on January 6, 2026, for $7,500,000. The company's deed history includes 26 Stone Harbor transfers since 2016. Two earlier pairs follow the same pattern. It bought 10017 Corinthian Drive for $1,930,000 in April 2021 and sold it for $5,000,000 in September 2022. It bought 179 113th Street for $3,900,000 in June 2023 and sold it for $7,545,000 in August 2024. The company was also the buyer of record for 11100 Second Avenue, one of the Villa lots sold this January.
Three other LLCs each show one purchase and one sale in the past two years:
11501 Paradise Drive has the longest record. Charles Street Developers bought it for $2,200,000 in January 2019 and sold it for $4,850,000 in February 2020. The Cape May County Herald reported that the same address sold for $9,815,500 on November 6, 2026. That was the second-highest sale on Seven Mile Island that week.
Few Stone Harbor deeds are market sales. In the Herald's dashboard for November 13, 2025, through November 9, 2026, Stone Harbor recorded 223 deed transfers, and only 94 of them were priced sales. The median was $3,102,000. The Herald leaves transfers under $1,000 out of its price statistics. It describes them as typically nominal transfers, such as family moves and $1 deeds. That means more than half of the deeds recorded in Stone Harbor that year were not market sales.
The most expensive Stone Harbor transfer of that 12-month period was 339 104th Street, which sold for $15,301,000 on September 16, 2026. Some older homes are torn down and replaced. In July, the Herald reported that the zoning board approved demolishing a 1935 bungalow at 259 99th Street to make way for a new home.
The borough has also noticed the rise in values. In November 2025, Stone Harbor said property values had "increased dramatically" since its 2018 reassessment. It approved $675,000 for a new reassessment, with work starting in 2026 and possibly taking two years.
For a buyer comparing towns, these records give a practical way to read listings. An older house on a full Stone Harbor lot priced near $4 million is priced close to what the land alone has sold for on 111th and 112th Streets since 2023. Anyone bidding on that house may be competing with LLCs that have been paying land prices on the same streets. The two Villa lots that resold near $7.5 million brought roughly $3 million or more above what the land had cost.
The town median mixes both kinds of sale. For the 90 days ending November 9, the Herald dashboard shows a $3,650,000 median across 34 priced Stone Harbor sales. That number blends sales near land price with sales well above it. It is most useful once you can tell which kind each sale was. For how Stone Harbor compares with the rest of Seven Mile Island, see how the Avalon luxury market compares along the Jersey Cape. If you are planning to sell, see what Stone Harbor's resale certificate checks.
Is Villa Maria by the Sea still there? Yes. The sisters dedicated a new, smaller Villa on May 15, 2023, on part of the property they first bought in the 1930s.
Did any Villa Maria lots sell far outside the $4 million range? Yes. 105 and 115 112th Street sold for $11.25 million and $5.25 million in 2023. Every other lot sold between $3,595,000 and $4,350,000.
Where can I look up a specific Stone Harbor sale? The Cape May County Herald's property records list recorded transfers by address, block and lot, with the buyer, seller and price, and earlier transfers of the same parcel.
If you own an older home on a full Stone Harbor lot, you will want to know how its price compares with what land on your street has been selling for. Teresa Campama can pull the recorded sales for your block and walk you through them. Start with a free home valuation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.